|
Reviews For The Minstrel Boy

Name: Holly Ilex (Signed) · Date: 01/02/10 1:20 PM · Chapter: The Minstrel Boy

You no good, low down, mangy old, egg sucking DOG! YOU MADE ME CRY!!!!!! and I DID read the other story!

Actually, this was a great way of filling in that little time gap and give the details of what happened to the Creevey brother during the battle.

Good blending of the 'canon' parts, song and your own delightful story ( everyone really SHOULD read that one, it's a hoot! )



Author's Response: Sorry'bout that! - OK who said that in canon? hehe...You're saving up for the Review-a-thon, aren't you? Can't wait to hear your thoughts on the midterm conclusion of "New Marauders"!  Here I thought you'd vanished or something, too. Glad you enjoyed it, and thanks for the review.


Name: Georgia Weasley (Signed) · Date: 17/01/10 4:15 PM · Chapter: The Minstrel Boy
A Horcrux of Light is a brilliant and refreshingly new idea! I had plans on a Colin story that I never could quite get off the ground. Now, I don't know that I should. Yours is simply wonderful. The details about Snape's treatment of the students, and how he paid Colin and rewarded him for restoring Lily's picture before placing a Confidentiality curse on him was spot on. The pain of the brothers' separation was well done, and the imagery of the war and Colin's brutal death was tragic. Excellent story.

Author's Response: Thank you, Georgia! I hope you finished New Marauders first, though??? By all means, don't let this deter you from writing a Colin story. I see so few of them out there.


Name: Kreacher (Signed) · Date: 13/01/10 10:51 AM · Chapter: The Minstrel Boy
I know I've already reviewed ths, but I want to suggest that you take this and run with it. Show how Colin adjusted to his "new" life, having and older younger brother as well as other things like working out what the heck happened to him. There must be some things, information and such that will tell Colin that he wasn't just "in a coma".

Author's Response: Thanks, again, Kreacher. I will have to give this a lot of thought before I even  outline it, though!


Name: Kreacher (Signed) · Date: 12/01/10 12:12 PM · Chapter: The Minstrel Boy
Excelent! Please write more. You do so well.

Author's Response: Thank you! I am glad you found it. I think everyone is saving up for the Review-a-Thon!


You must login (register) to review.