Name: Georgia Weasley (Signed) ·
Date: 10/09/2008 04:43 pm ·
Chapter: Cupboard Cliche's
Very cute. I loved the reaction the teenage Charlie had to Tonks McGonagall touching him! How EWWWW is that? Very good. Fluff isn't terrible. It's like potato chips, you know they're bad for you but you just can't stop until you've made yourself sick. I liked this one!
Author's Response: Couldn't agree more on the fluff front - so bad, but you NEED it. Glad you liked this one! :) xxx
Name: Eyriana (Signed) ·
Date: 06/09/2008 04:01 pm ·
Chapter: Cupboard Cliche's
Awwww! This is adorable, Andy! I'm starting to love Charlie/Tonks (started with Merlin's a Sadist, now here) and the funny thing is, before Gubby's story it never even clicked as a ship to me. Dunno why... But this is hilarious and adorable. I bet your sister loved it!
Blaire
Author's Response: Hahaha - this certainly isn't the best Charlie/Tonks (Chonks? :P) there is about, but I'm so pleased you like it nonetheless. :)I think I've always shipped these two, so I'm glad you liked them. :) xx
Name: Labby (Signed) ·
Date: 21/05/2008 07:04 am ·
Chapter: Cupboard Cliche's
Ah.. a nice Charlie story.. my favorite! I loved it. I thought it was really cute and I love the whole play on cliches. It's nice thinking that there was something going on between Charlie and Tonks at one point - I adore those two. Great job with this story - I really liked it!
Author's Response: Haha the thing with cliches is that ultimately, they are tired because we use them and we love them. I'm really pleased you liked this - I like to think there was something going on too. :) xxx
Name: ginwannabe (Signed) ·
Date: 29/03/2008 03:34 pm ·
Chapter: Cupboard Cliche's
How cute is this? I was so puzzled at first, wondering what on earth Charlie was doing in a broom cupboard with a flirty McGonagall, LOL. I'm a little slow this morning. Really fun, Andy!
Author's Response: Haha aren't we all in the mornings? Glad you liked this, T. :) x
Name: Baby Sister (Anonymous) · Date: 29/03/2008 08:00 am · Chapter: Cupboard Cliche's
I loved it!! My second favorite you written. Thank you!
Author's Response: Thank you, sweeite! I'm glad you loved it! xxx
Name: justlikemagic (Signed) ·
Date: 28/03/2008 08:09 pm ·
Chapter: Cupboard Cliche's
So second time lucky - hope this one works!
10/10 for you, andypandy! That is just about the most ADORABLE thing I've read in about a million years. SO CUTE and SO FLUFFY and just basically GORGEOUS. I love it to the stars and back.
As you know, I got a little confused at the beginning, but actually I think it was great that I had to keep reading to find out what happened - good narrative hook, you English student, you!
I love how you even got Tonk's clumsiness in there, too! Fantastic! I had this silly little grin on my face all the way through this short 'n' sweet little story, all their flirting and Tonk's hair changing with her mood ... <3
Your Charlie is great! How old are they in this? I hope he's not too young for me to steal and marry :P This was sooo cute, I know I keep saying it but it really was! For something you must've spun out in one morning it's really an excellent job. You can tell you had fun writing it (or at least I assume you did!) because it's just so warm and grin-inducing.
I think you should do a collection of stories on this vein, but that's just me and my compulsion to feed my fluff addiction! Seriously, though, this is really gorgeous stuff.
I love it. That's all :D
Name: InsanityRulz (Signed) ·
Date: 28/03/2008 05:04 pm ·
Chapter: Cupboard Cliche's
Hey Andy! Your message in shout box caught me and here I am!!
Charlie and Tonks? Ooh. Never read that one before. Well, except for my friend's attempt at it. She deserted it after the first chapter. So well...reading on.
This part made me laugh - ‘You were sad?’ he asked leaning over and squeezing her hand. ‘Why? I mean I know we’re stuck, but I don’t smell that bad.’
I think you mixed up 'consolation' and 'conciliation'? Or maybe I am wrong...
Aw, total fluff. I really really enjoyed reading this Andykins! Awesome :)
Author's Response: Hey Jan! Thanks for popping by! I've never written them either! :) LOL - I rather liked that line too - I tired to use all the cliches I could! You were right about the mix up - silly me for trusting Word without looking! I'm glad you enjoyed it! :D ~ andy x x x
Name: JLHufflepuff (Signed) ·
Date: 28/03/2008 01:51 pm ·
Chapter: Cupboard Cliche's
Awww! This is sooo cute and fluffy! I love it.
Author's Response: Hehehehe! thanks so much for stopping by! I'm glad you liked it! :D x x xx