| Login |
Reviews For A Promise Sealed

Name: datbenik513 (Signed) · Date: 12/06/2009 08:37 am · Chapter: A Promise Sealed

OK, I have som e mixed feelings upon reading your one-shot.

I always love reading stories on the "missing moments" which had never made it to any of the books. This one is no difference and I immensely enjoyed it.

Susan is very believably written, two thumbs up for that, and Blaise in the first half is also very Slytherin. He, however, takes a U-turn as he gets disturbed by the series of killings and something makes him rethink if this is the path he wants to take. Also a very valid emotion. 

At the end, the metamorphose is complete. I don't deny I was somewhat flabbergasted at the scale of this metamorphose, still, I do like happy ends.

My only criticism would be that for a one-shot there's simply too much happening. I can imagine this plot expanded into 8-10 2k-words chapters and it still would not be slow-paced at all. Too many events, too many changes before it could get boring.

Other than that, I enjoyed it very much. Nice, clean, literate writing, sealed by a powerful last sentence.



Name: Holly Ilex (Signed) · Date: 19/09/2008 08:25 pm · Chapter: A Promise Sealed

Good, one Slytherin at a time. . . and before you knon it, Baldie Voldie is out of 'volunteers'. 

I used the ' ' because you know as well as I that most of his 'followers' were actually herded into the group, too scared to say no or blackmailed/ threatened into joining.

GOod for Susan in seeing the 'good' in him and knowing she'll help him, no matter what. Hope their furture turns out all right.

Pansy can stick it up her nose.  Oh, wait. . .  that would be rather painful, wouldn't it pug face?

HE!HE!HE!



Author's Response: Omg, thank you so much for your whopperful review, Holly. You are crazy, you know that? :P ily.


Name: Georgia Weasley (Signed) · Date: 10/09/2008 04:47 am · Chapter: A Promise Sealed
Interesting turn of events. The description is very well written. I do wonder why most people go AU and do not make Blaise African like JK did, but go figure. I think Slytherin needed another good looking guy in there with Draco. Crabbe and Goyle just weren't cutting it! I liked that you brought Susan to life, even though you had very little to go on from canon. Very good.

Author's Response: I didn't Blaise was African when I wrote it fic. It was a long time ago. Now I do know, but you are right, Slytherin DOES need a pretty boy aside from Draco. lol. Thanks for your honest opinion. *hugs*


Name: ginwannabe (Signed) · Date: 07/06/2008 04:58 pm · Chapter: A Promise Sealed
Blaise and Susan Bones?  Almost as warped as The Fat Lady and Sir Cadagon...but not quite.  This was interesting.  I can perhaps see a Blaise/Susan ship, although I don't know that it would have been such a quick turnaround for Blaise.  This was sweet though.

Author's Response: Yeah, well, I didn't get to explore their relationship in detail since it's a one-shot. But I am satisfied. Thanks so much for your review, Taryn. *adores*


You must login (register) to review.