Name: granpa harry (Signed) ·
Date: 20/12/2012 03:13 am ·
Chapter: Dobby Lives On - The Sock Story
WOW
what a great story for Christmas.
Glad I went looking.
GH
Name: pookha (Signed) ·
Date: 06/12/2009 08:42 pm ·
Chapter: Dobby Lives On - The Sock Story
I can't believe I hadn't reveiewed this before, especially since I love Dobby so much. His death and Hedwig's hit me hardest of anyone in the entire series of books, even more than Fred.
This is a beautiful, sweet and charming fable and I love the ending. Definitely a Christmas charmer. Warm, comfortable fluff in which to wrap a good feeling for humanity and elf-kind.
Name: BKL8008 (Signed) ·
Date: 14/12/2008 06:55 pm ·
Chapter: Dobby Lives On - The Sock Story
What a surprise of an ending to a lovely story.
You capture James so well, as it's impossible to tell stories to some overly analytical children. I know!
10/10
Name: Holly Ilex (Signed) ·
Date: 14/09/2008 03:36 am ·
Chapter: Dobby Lives On - The Sock Story
What a lovely story!
I like the Christmas angle of having Dobby integrated, slowly but surely, back into Harry's ( and his family's ) life.
I know it's painful for Harry to think of Dobby, but this is a good way of remembering him, and honoring him, too.
Well done!
Name: Georgia Weasley (Signed) ·
Date: 30/08/2008 04:45 am ·
Chapter: Dobby Lives On - The Sock Story
This was absolutely beautiful. What a tribute to poor Dobby, to think that he would be the elf to save Christmas. He was such a pure and selfless little soul. I think you did a great job in this, and having James be the one to do the socks to help his Dad feel better was just so sweet. This is a great piece of writing.
Name: Jen (Signed) ·
Date: 04/06/2008 04:29 am ·
Chapter: Dobby Lives On - The Sock Story
Truly beautiful Elena. A fitting tribute to brave little Dobby, thankyou. I'll have to tell this story to my girls - they always wear odd socks and they just adore Dobby.
Name: ginwannabe (Signed) ·
Date: 11/02/2008 05:30 am ·
Chapter: Dobby Lives On - The Sock Story
How sweet is James for helping Albus to believe? And *sigh* I cried so hard when Dobby died. What a brave little elf. I loved the whole story, Dobby, Santa, the socks. I loved the way the boys interjected into the story. I could picture and hear it all in my head. Well done!
Name: x-happygirl (Signed) ·
Date: 28/01/2008 05:26 am ·
Chapter: Dobby Lives On - The Sock Story
ZOMGSQUEE!!
I love this!! Much better detail than your first story, I have to admit. I've never been so sad about a pair of socks. I like Kreacher's character- I think it is what he'd be acting like after the whole DH ordeal. This story is like hyperactiveness... it keeps going until you get to a peak and then it stops... but not without a good ending :D I loved it and it finished really well. Ok James is so sweet! I claim him now, out of randomness, lol. Anyway I loved the story and I think it ended well. I thought Dobby's story was cute and I think I"ll tell it next Christmas to my little cousin. And I feel like floor surfing now... OK I loved it. :DD
Name: andharrywokeup (Signed) ·
Date: 08/01/2008 08:23 am ·
Chapter: Dobby Lives On - The Sock Story
Oh Elena. You actually have no idea how happy you have just made me. I'm a fan of Christmas, sock sliding and Dobby! I cried buckets at his death (more than at any other point in the novel) and I don't think I've smiled at the mention of his name until this story! You written Harry as a truly gorgeous father and developed a wonderful family unit. I laughed out loud as Ginny rushed out of bed to get dressed before climbing back in to act surprised! And your James...little James, just how adorable?! All the future generation fics that I've read thus far, like with JKR's epilogue,have tended to focus on Albus, so it was nice to see James in a positive light! And your Lily giggling in the morning was so grogeous! I grinned like a fool throughout! Fantastic!
Name: Angel (Signed) ·
Date: 03/01/2008 07:04 pm ·
Chapter: Dobby Lives On - The Sock Story
That was absolutely lovely! I loved it! Very original and such a sweet look into the future of the Potter family. I love how Harry is with his children, and the chemistry between him and Ginny is perfect. Even though I know that you are as much a D/G shipper as I am. Oh and the floor surfing scene made me burst out loud!!Thank you for that it was wonderful!!
Author's Response: Thank you *huggle* I enjoyed writing this little piece and it gave me a new desire to write Next Gen stories...Perhaps even with an AU twist! I'm glad that this story is getting lots of positive reviews, I wasn't sure if I was writing the children right, but I haven't had any negative feedback yet, so, that makes me happy!